Gyre is going to get the chance to see their disappointed face because it doesn't go away even as he makes his way onto the shore. He can cough and sputter and make all the reactions he wanted, but they're not going to really care about what he does in this moment because of one very, very important fact:

"You said show you." They say in the most betrayed voice ever. How dare you be rude at them for something you chose, Gyre?