"HGH!" he grunts as she slams into him, entirely unprepared for the sudden shift in tone. He thought he'd get a little warning first! The impact makes his wounds scream, his whole body on fire as she crushes him into himself.

Then he's in the air, his vision spinning wildly and all filled with flashing colors. He struggles in her grip, his hand trapped against his side but nearly close enough that he can grab the end of the arrow. He tugs it more firmly into his palm, and kicks his legs out, trying to strike her in the armpit so she'll uhhh let him go??

Regardless of whether this works or not, when he feels her pull away, he's going to try striking out wildly with the arrow, attempting to cut her the second she gives him an opening. He's still playing her dumb game, even if she's not.