When Joanna chooses to agree with him, well, Garrot's ego inflates enough that he starts to actually think about the things coming out of his mouth. He's got someone to entertain after all!

"Oh... oh no." He blinks a few times, staring off into the distance. "What if she is like a cat!? And what if the monsters are too?!" His voice is tinged with disbelief, shock, and just a little bit of amusement, so there's some kind of limit on how seriously he's taking this.

"I mean, cats hate water, right? And we got one of the second monsters wet, and it was not happy. And the monsters just kinda do whatever they want. So does the Wizard." A beat. "Should we dump a bucket of water on her?"

Wizard. Not a Witch.